Mexico Issues & Opinions

Puerto Vallarta • Riviera Nayarit 

  News &
Issues &
Business &
Health &
Lifestyle &
Travel &
Science &

In the Face of 'America First,' Why Mexican Nationalism Is Not the Answer

Gema Santamaria - openDemocracy
go to original
April 19, 2017

In February, tens of thousands of Mexicans demonstrated against US President Donald Trump and their own President Enrique Peña Nieto (Al Jazeera English)

The feasibility of U.S.-Mexico cooperation is under challenge. President Trump’s approach to the bilateral relation on matters of security, migration, and trade has been driven by unilateral, aggressive, and exclusionary proposals. Although most of these proposals have yet to translate into concrete policies, they have already proven to be detrimental for the trust and potential cooperation between the two countries.

In terms of security cooperation, for instance, Trump has privileged a defensive, militarized, and reactive discourse. His proposed “great wall” aimed to fortify the U.S.-Mexico border synthetizes his conception of security; one in which the “bad hombres” are kept outside the U.S. territory by simply closing off the border and increasing police and military presence, all without the cooperation - less so the consent - of its southern neighbor. The notion of shared responsibility, which shaped the Mérida Initiative and informed most cooperation under the past administrations, has been virtually abandoned. Instead, Mexico has been presented to the U.S. public as the sole bearer of America’s security challenges – from illegal migration to availability of drugs and common crime.

In the face of this unilateral and aggressive approach to the bilateral relation, what can (or should) Mexico do? Mexico’s response towards Trump has been, up until now, equivocal at best. From Trump’s visit to Mexico as presidential candidate, to President Peña Nieto’s cancelled visit to the U.S. in the midst of Trump’s twitter declarations, Mexico has proven incapable of articulating a coherent message towards Trump’s provocations. For some, this expresses Peña Nieto’s government lack of strategy on matters of foreign policy; for others, it only reflects the natural challenges that a U.S. twitter-driven and erratic foreign policy poses for Mexico or for any other country used to traditional diplomatic channels.

Beyond this official response, however, Mexico’s reaction to Trump has also included a revival of nationalism, from people on the left but also on the center and right of the political spectrum. This revival includes disjointed calls on social media to boycott “gringo” companies - most notably Starbucks - and to consume “only national” products, as well as appeals made to Twitter, Facebook, and Facebook users to feature the Mexican flag on their profile pictures. It furthermore involves public demands to defend the dignity and honor of the nation by expressing solidarity with the Mexican government as well as overt repudiation towards Trump’s politics. It is such nationalistic spirit that informed the anti-Trump mobilization convoked on February 12th under the names “Vibra México” (Mexico vibes) and “Mexicanos unidos” (Mexican united). It is also this mood which has informed publications and statements made by some Mexican public intellectuals and figures. For instance, the last issue of Letras Libres, directed by Enrique Krauze, features in its cover an image that emulates Mexico’s national emblem: the Mexican eagle devours a snake that, in this case, wears a blond Trump-style hairdo. One article in the issue identifies Trump’s provocations as an opportunity to assert a “morally superior” position on behalf of Mexico, while another one openly identifies Mexico’s nationalism as an asset vis-à-vis the U.S. government’s suggestion to renegotiate or abandon NAFTA.

A call for nationalism is, however, the wrong answer to Trump’s policies. Beyond its shortsighted and potentially chauvinistic nature, a call for nationalism can very easily translate into a call for loyalty and lack of criticism towards the current government. History has demonstrated that anti-American sentiments can and have been used by political elites in moments of crisis, as a means to create consensus, overcome divisiveness, and even conceal a government’s lack of legitimacy. In a moment when citizens need to make their government accountable for the impunity, corruption, and human rights abuses impacting the country, nationalism cannot be an option.

Mexico’s response to Trump should assert the country’s commitment to multilateralism and international cooperation, not only in terms of trade - which at times seems to be the only issue on the agenda - but on matters of security, human rights, and the rule of law. A critique of Trump’s securitized understanding of immigration should also include a critique of Mexico’s own failure to adopt a more integral migration policy in its southern border, one that is capable of protecting Central American immigrants from the rampage of organized crime. Furthermore, a critical stance towards Trump’s reactive and militarized vision of security should also involve a call to move beyond Mexico’s own militarized, short-term, and repressive response toward insecurity and violence.

Frustrated by the anticipated failure of the above-mentioned anti-Trump mobilization, Enrique Krauze twittered that not attending the protest was a sign of “passivity, indifference, and even cowardice” on behalf of Mexican citizens. The failure of the anti-Trump mobilization is not, however, to be found in the so-called cowardice of Mexicans. It is to be found in the incapacity to move beyond a call for nationalism that has been paired with an uncritical stance towards Mexican’s own government. Mexico does not need nationalistic and “brave” citizens. It needs, instead, a citizenry committed to international cooperation, transparency, and critical engagement that can call into question another government’s equivocal policies while remaining critical of its own.

See the original at openDemocracy | Español

We invite you to add your charity or supporting organizations' news stories and coming events to PVAngels so we can share them with the world. Do it now!

CHARITY ALERT Vallarta Botanical Garden Needs Your Help

TripAdvisor singled out the Botanical Garden for removal and placed us on our own page in Cabo Corrientes.

Please write and ask TripAdvisor why all other Cabo Corrientes attractions are still on the Puerto Vallarta page while only the Garden was removed.

Click here to see all the details

Meet the Charities

Community Services


Animals & Wildlife

Health Care

Youth & Family


Culture & Recreation

Special Interests

How You Can Help

Use Your Powers for Good

Add Your Favorite Charity

Save a Life - Give Blood


Partners for Change

Meet the Partners

Become a Partner for Change

Stay Connected

Find PVAngels on Facebook Follow PVAngels on Twitter Sign up PVAngels Newsletter RSS Feeds on PVAngels


About PVAngels

Add Your Charity

Add Your News & Events

Locate Yourself on Our Maps

Jobs - Join PVAngels Team

About Puerto Vallarta

Puerto Vallarta Local News

Local Event Calendar

Puerto Vallarta Videos

Puerto Vallarta Photos

Historic Puerto Vallarta

Local Area Maps

Important Phone Numbers

Craig's List in Puerto Vallarta

News Around Mexico

Mexico Issues & Opinions

Mexico Business News

Mexico Evironmental News

Lifestyle & Entertainment

Mexico Travel & Outdoors

Science & Technology News

Mexico News & Travel Videos

FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance a more in-depth understanding of critical issues facing the world. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 USC Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

m3 • local actions from global awareness